Geography and Cancer
Have you ever wondered if there is a geographical tie to cancer? Science has found that certain exposures correlate to a cancer diagnosis. For instance, a direct tie to uranium mining in southern Utah was found when researching a cancer cluster in Moab, Utah (http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/pgms/worknotify/uranium.html). Geography is so important in understanding our physical health. It entails the air quality we breath everyday, the quality of water we drink, the types of businesses that surround us and the business practices they use that impact us. Geography can describe many aspects of our lives like where we go to work and what we do for work, where we go to school, where we shop, and where we leisure. All these things are included in our personal geographies and have potential impacts for good and bad on our health.
This is a Utah community mapping project serving to engage the public and inform the public about the geography of cancer in the state of Utah. This project allows us to explore the geographical question and potentially find correlation between geography and cancer by allowing we the people, the general public, to input our geographical area of diagnosis along with pertinent information to observe potential geographical patterns.
This project also serves to observe the location of cancer at an individual scale without revealing details of who the individual is, thereby keeping confidentiality.
I want to hear from you too! Please comment, post on my Facebook page, and send messages!
If you have cancer and live in Utah, or lived in Utah, I encourage you to participate if you are 18 years of age or older. If you are the parent of a child under the age of 18 with cancer please participate.Please read the section I'm Just a Lady on a Mission to get to know me a little better.
The goal of this project is to engage the citizens of Utah in a public participatory mapping project that ties together social and ecological systems that surround us, and the potential impacts we could be experiencing from them, specifically cancer. The information you contribute is for public knowledge, and will help all of us come a step closer in understanding the link between exposures and cancer.
The map for documenting your cancer is on the right. Follow the simple steps provided.
~Rules~
Disclaimer
Sunday, October 26, 2014
Question of the week.
She has given me a lot of food for thought and I think I need to address it. Here is her question to me:
"I’m 51 years old and was diagnosed with thyroid cancer about three years ago. Although I was born in Utah and lived there for most of my life, I have actually lived in San Francisco for the past 20 years. I can’t help but think that my cancer could be associated with growing up, and living in Utah—In Provo for the first 18 years of life, and in SLC for the next 10.
But I want to ask you: Do you think my cancer is relevant for the map? And if so, would you suggest I map my address in Provo or in SLC?If my cancer is even relevant for the map, I am inclined to map Provo bc I suspect that exposure to pesticides, herbicides, the pollution from Geneva Steel, and maybe even radioactive fallout from above ground nuclear tests in Nevada while I was young might have something to do with the cancer I eventually developed. Just thought I’d ask your opinion.
Thanks,
Barbara"
My thought for Barbara was to allow her to add her area of residence when she was living in Utah, and just noting that she was not diagnosed in Utah, but lived most of her life here. I can't actually use her data because of the way I have set this project up. This is a huge limiting factor that I think can be addressed and studied.
With further thought, I am thinking it would be good to post a second map for people in this same situation, allowing those that have lived most of their life in Utah and was diagnosed outside of Utah with cancer.
I was given permission from Barbara to post her comments and share my thought about it, because really, any one of us could have been exposed to something outside of Utah as well.
Thank you Barbara for contacting me and allowing me to share your diagnosis and thoughtful questions. I hope you are healthy and doing well.
This project will only get better with comments and questions and consideration made by everyone taking part and thinking about this geographic question.
I will create a second map for people living outside of Utah that have received a cancer diagnosis, but grew-up here, or spent significant years here. I will enable it to collect information just as the local's map does, but with questions more appropriate for those not living here anymore. This will take a couple of days to build so I will create a new post when it is complete.
Becky
Friday, October 24, 2014
This Week
It doesn't seem fair that while we grieve the world continues moving forward unaware, not even stopping for a moment to recognize the terrible loss. We go to the store and see strangers functioning normally, completely oblivious to what has transpired. You almost want to stop everyone you meet and tell them about the tragedy so they too will stop and take a moment to think about this person.
Even more profound for me in this loss (I am not naming names because I didn't seek permission to mention him) is that he lived next door to a dear friend of mine, the women that cared for me during my cancer treatment, and the women whom died just over a year ago from leukemia, Sandy Glauser. Sandy lived next door to the house this little guy lived in. Sandy had since moved to my neck of the woods and was not living in that house when she was diagnosed. She is one of reasons why I ask in the map database about previous residences. As many of you know, cancer is a latent disease that can grow in the body without notice for some time, or it may not even start growing upon immediate exposure to something that causes cancer, like radiation exposure. In my instance it was a latent exposure that sealed my fate.
So for this week, no lecture or discussion from me about exposure or treating our planet as a system we are all a part of so don't mess it up. This week my thoughts are with those that have lost the battle, it is with the caregivers that grieve for the loss and the struggle they never signed up for, it is with those facing the horrific decisions that come with agreeing to treatments that by default not just kill cancer, but injure all our organs and tissues.
Cancer sucks.
Becky
Friday, October 10, 2014
The Solution to Pollution is Dilution...Right?
WHY ARE YOU SHARING THIS LAME STORY you may be asking right about now. Well, I will tell you. Let me get to that in a minute.. I had to clear out all of the wood bark and send it to a waste facility for lead so it wasn't sitting in my yard where my little girl would be digging in it or running through it, or planting flowers or something. Good timing, because the next day she wanted to plant bulbs for next spring in just those spots where I had removed the bark (I still hosed the area down so as to not make dust while digging with her). I had a fabulous Ecology professor years ago who would sheepishly say "The solution to pollution is dilution" in class to get a rise out of his students because we know in the 21st century this thinking is ridiculous and incorrect. Dilution will not eliminate the pollution, and in fact it works to collect it, contain it, and greater concentrations accumulate.
The Water Cycle:
Water (rain or snow) hits the earth, thereby watering land, adding water and ice to rivers, streams and the ocean. Water evaporates and is taken up again into the atmosphere where it will eventually fall to earth again as rain or snow...blah.
In a nutshell, the water cycle can be applied in a general way to my yard and lead issue, though the evapotranporation and evaporation from water bodies isn't important for the story.... Don't fall asleep just yet, you are about to learn something valuable! Let's imagine the lead dust is industry or car emissions. Five days a week these emissions are accumulating in Utah air and because of our bowl shaped topography in the north of the state along the Wasatch Mountains, a lot of these emissions get trapped (I can get into why that happens in a different post). So the air gets more dirty with each passing day, especially during regular business hours for those are the hours the factories are running and we are commuting the most. Some Utahns like me with lung issues are impacted first and have to use an inhaler occasionally. But let's say that the hose comes in to save the day, or actually it rains heavily enough to clear the air of the accumulated emissions. GREAT right? Yes, great the air is clean to breath, but what happened to all those emissions? Brace yourselves because we don't have an earth with removable bark that can be taken away and processed....they went into your garden soil, our rivers and streams, our lakes and oceans and have to be filtered out so we can drink our tap water. The emissions didn't actually go away. They just changed mediums. I found this cute diagram of the water cycle I thought you might like from phil.gov. It is missing however the life and habitat that then has to live with the pollution once it falls to our soil or water, and runs into streams and lakes, like fish, and plant life like our food crops! Yikes!
Wednesday, October 8, 2014
Agents of Change
We grow up and find that the world is a big place, with lots of other people with ideas and agendas. Sometimes these ideas and agendas conflict with making the world a better place as we would define it. I think the world, if it takes into account it's actions and how all that we do impacts everyone else, thereby impacting the world with the least amount of harm, would be a pretty good place considering all of the agendas. This idea pops in my head when I read about chemicals in wood products like decking material that cause cancer, or the use of pesticides which are also considered carcinogens by the Department of Health. I hope the companies that manufacture these things take action and change their processes to exclude such chemicals so the impact they have on the world is not cancer.
There are non-profit groups along with the American Cancer Society that publish information regarding environmental cancer causation. If you take the time to look through the information it can help guard you and your family, your business practices, and prevent potential negative impacts if you are informed. Here is the link for the American Cancer Society
: http://www.cancer.org/cancer/cancercauses/othercarcinogens/generalinformationaboutcarcinogens/known-and-probable-human-carcinogens
A group that I really like is the Environmental Working Group (EWG). It is a non-profit working to inform the public about environmental impacts in air, water, food, and consumer products, and the potential impacts they have on us. The EWG provides list of foods and consumer products that contain dangerous levels of chemicals found to be toxic to humans. They also publish lists of foods and consumer items that are safe for humans. Weird that someone has to do this these days, but I am glad they do. Here is a link to their website: http://www.ewg.org/ I suggest you take the time to check it out and my guess is you will be impressed.
I think my elementary teacher was right, we can impact the work in a positive way as change agents. If we educate ourselves and act on what we have learned.
I hope you all have a great week and make positive impacts in the world as agents of change.
Becky
Friday, October 3, 2014
Then there was a lump...
I am a mother of one and a wife, and I am a cancer survivor. I have incorporated "survivor" into my most basic identity and uphold this part of my identity as sacred and something not to be challenged in level of importance. I have survived thus far a terrible disease, but I also cared for, and lost someone to the disease, so I feel I have earned the badge. I have had mixed reactions and questions when the topic of cancer survivorship comes up. One person asked if I have started running marathons now that I have survived cancers because that is what they thought cancer survivors did! I did laugh and have to disappoint them with a "no", though I hope as my body gets stronger I will in the future.
I have made great effort to find meaning in the experience and I haven't stopped searching for that meaning. I mentioned I cared for someone that I lost to cancer; that would be my youngest brother Stephen. He died in 2007 from a terrible brain cancer that has yet to be classified. The Brigham and Women's Center at Harvard Medical School is still studying his case posthumously. When he died, though I was an adult, logical and strong adult, I couldn't get past the experience I shared with my family caring for him and loosing him. I kept asking myself "what did this to him?" I needed closure so badly on this issue that I went back to school to understand better what the potential cause was for this terrible ending for my brother. I had combed the medical journals and found that the scale of research on these tumors was on the cellular and genetic scale making it difficult to "see" what external factors could have set some horrific cellular reaction, or done damage to his genes. I wanted to know the potential environmental impacts that could have started this reaction in his body. When I say "environmental" I mean anything around us like the water we drink, the air we breath, the chemical we are exposed to, the viruses we are exposed to, medicines we may take, all things that have a geographic significance at some scale. I ended up obtaining a degree in Geography and emphasizing in Environmental Science, and Technical Geography (which comes in real handy later).
I had appeased my desire to understand potentially what had happened to my brother. I had moved forward with a career and just had my daughter, when out running one day (not a marathon) a little voice in my head screamed from under the podcast I was listening to, to check for lumps. My cousin and uncle had just been diagnosed with cancer the previous week. I figured that my deep fear of cancer and the high level of stress it had brought to my family had finally psyched me out! Again, and not one of those quiet thoughts you have type of voice, it screamed "check for lumps!" When I made it home I went straight to the bathroom mirror feeling very silly. I felt my armpits, my groin. I looked in the mirror and turned my head from side-to-side. When I turned my head left a large lump bubbled up from under my right clavicle. The voice said "You have cancer". In the coming year multiple neighbors were diagnosed with cancer as well, one of which did not make it.
I will jump ahead a few years. I lived! The pic on the left is a picture taken of me when I was about half way through treatment. I am kind of a goof-ball. I was cleared of cancer completely in 2012, and again threw myself back into school, this time studying the systems of environment and social factors on a graduate level in hope of understanding my cancer. My education has taught me how to see social and ecological systems playing out before us, and how impacts to and from these systems can have drastic and terrible impacts on us. For instance pollution in the air, or particles floating around the air we breath, can have little impact on some of us, but depending on the size of the particle, and lung health of the individual, and the amount of time of exposure to the particles, these little particles can cause lung damage. Lung damage is an expense and impacts largely elderly populations and adults and children with asthma. The federal government makes the regulatory laws that cap the amount of pollution that can be in the air at a given time. However, enforcing clean air is up to states. States who's economy is dependent, or gets a good chunk of money from industries that might pollute the air may find it hard to enforce clean air laws if it could hurt their economy. Do you see where I am going with this?
I won't put you to sleep, unless you are already asleep.
Mapping people that have suffered a cancer diagnosis can do a number of things to help understand the "system" a little better. It can show us if cancer is clustering (if there is a high amount of people in one small area, with small area being the key), it can identify where a lack of treatment is geographically in relation to the people needing treatment, it can bring neighbors together that are going through the same experience, and it can potentially identify geographic exposures that could be causing cancer. This is where my Technical Geography training comes into play and my graduate degree. If I can get enough people to participate we, and I do mean "we" can accomplish all of these things.
Don't be shy. Post your comments or questions. You can contact me via e-mail at the bottom of the page.


